Friday, January 3, 2020
`` The Genderless Baby Well Intentioned But Wrong ``
Imagine living in a world where not knowing whatââ¬â¢s under a personââ¬â¢s pants didnââ¬â¢t get under peopleââ¬â¢s skin because such private matters had never been a public thing. In an article from The Globe and Mail titled, ââ¬Å"The genderless baby? Well-intentioned but wrongâ⬠, author, Judith Timson, criticizes the parents of the aforementioned baby, Storm, and their decision to hide Stormââ¬â¢s gender. Brandishing the words of Lady Gaga as if she were a credible source of research, Timson argues that Stormââ¬â¢s parents are depriving the child of a sexual and gender identity by keeping his or her sex a secret. However, as valid as Timsonââ¬â¢s concerns are towards this controversial decision, it is important to note that Stormââ¬â¢s parents are not depriving Storm of his/her sex and consequently, Stormââ¬â¢s sexual/gender identity. If anything, the constant input of the public is the main struggle Storm will face in the exploration and developme nt of his/her identity. Therefore, the genderless baby at the center of this societal storm, is not so much in risk of being deprived an identity as Timson contends, rather the child is at risk of being denied one. In her article, Timson (2011) states that Stormââ¬â¢s parents have ââ¬Å"decided to keep the sex of their third child a secretâ⬠(p. 1), implying that this will deprive Storm of an identity. However, it is important to clarify that Stormââ¬â¢s parents, Witterick and Stock, are depriving the world of Stormââ¬â¢s sexual identity but not the child itself. As quoted by TimsonShow MoreRelatedGenderless Identity Does More Harm than Good1137 Words à |à 5 Pagestwo brothers. However, a decision was made by Stormââ¬â¢s parents to break the convention of identifying children by gender, and as a result the chance for Storm to be raised like others. Stormââ¬â¢s parents, Witterick and Stocker are indeed doing something wrong. Their extreme and unusual parenting decision would make Storm a lifelong victim of prejudice. According to Stormââ¬â¢s parents, they want to love their children for who they are, not what genitals they have; they want to be supportive of the individuality
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.